Tips
Out-of-Network Mental Health Claims: How to Submit Them and Check Your Reimbursement

Many families see out-of-network psychiatrists, psychologists, and therapists and then ask their plan to reimburse them. A complete claim gets processed faster. Knowing how insurers calculate payment helps you spot when you've been underpaid. This guide builds on resources from the Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project.
Part of our insurance resource series: Requesting treatment & prior authorization · Out-of-network claims & reimbursement · When your plan has no qualified providers · Appealing a denial · External review & expedited appeals
What a complete claim includes
Whether you file a claim form or a superbill from your provider, check that it includes:
The patient's name, address, and date of birth
The diagnosis code(s)
The procedure (CPT) code for each service. Facilities may also use revenue or HCPCS codes.
Each date of service, and the number of units where sessions are billed in time blocks
The treating clinician's name, National Provider Identifier (NPI), and license or certification number
The practice or facility name, address, NPI, and tax ID (EIN)
Missing items are a common reason claims get delayed or denied. If something looks incomplete, ask your provider's office before you submit. The Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project also publishes code crosswalks for psychological testing, neuropsychological testing, and ABA services, because those codes have changed over the years.
Send it so you can prove it arrived
Use certified mail or another trackable method, or ask your plan for a fax number or online upload option.
Keep copies of everything you send.
Call about a week later to confirm the claim was received.
Why reimbursement can be lower than you expect
Out-of-network benefits usually pay a percentage, such as 80%, of what the plan considers the "usual, customary, and reasonable" rate for that service in your area. They don't pay a percentage of what your provider actually charged. If the plan sets that allowed amount very low, your check can be a small share of the bill.
For example, if a session costs $150 but the plan decides $50 is "customary," 80% of the allowed amount is only $40.
How to check whether you were paid fairly
Read every Explanation of Benefits (EOB). Compare the allowed amount and payment to what your plan documents promise.
Look up typical costs. FAIR Health Consumer is an independent, free tool for estimating typical charges for a procedure code in your area.
Ask how the rate was calculated. Plans are generally required to explain how they set the allowed amount. If it isn't in your plan documents, request it in writing.
Appeal if the numbers don't add up. An underpaid claim can be appealed like a denial. See our guide to appealing a denial.
If your coverage is through a large employer
If your employer self-funds its health plan, let HR or the benefits administrator know when out-of-network reimbursement isn't keeping up with market rates. Employers can push their plan administrators to fix it.
Where to get more help
The Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project is a nonprofit that helps California families get mental health and autism care covered by insurance. Its Requesting Treatments & Managing Denials guide is the basis for this series, and the team there can help with complex cases. Visit mhautism.org for its full set of resources.
How Refine Psychiatry fits in
Refine Psychiatry is an out-of-network practice. We don't bill insurance directly, but we can give you a superbill to submit to your plan for possible reimbursement. When your plan asks for clinical documentation, we can also prepare letters as a listed service. You can see our current fees on our services page and our billing transparency page. Questions? Contact our team.
This article is general information for patients and families. It is not legal, insurance, or financial advice. Insurance rules vary by plan type and state and can change, so confirm the details with your plan, your plan documents, or a qualified advocate.


