Tips
Insurance Denied Your Mental Health Treatment? How to Appeal

A denial isn't necessarily the final word. Many denials of mental health and autism care can be challenged, and a well-organized appeal makes a difference. This guide draws on the work of the Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project, which writes appeals for California families.
Part of our insurance resource series: Requesting treatment & prior authorization · Out-of-network claims & reimbursement · When your plan has no qualified providers · Appealing a denial · External review & expedited appeals
Grievance or appeal: which one do you need?
Grievance (complaint): you're unhappy with how your case is being handled, but you haven't received a formal denial.
Appeal: you received a denial. That can be a denial letter, or an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) showing a claim was unpaid or underpaid.
The two main types of denials
Medical necessity denials dispute whether you need the treatment. They can also dispute how much, what type, how long, or in what setting. If the plan's internal appeal doesn't resolve it, these disputes can usually go to an independent external review.
Administrative denials cover almost everything else. Examples include a service the plan says isn't covered, network problems, missing pre-authorization, and underpaid claims. Help with these comes from your state regulator if your plan is fully insured, or from the U.S. Department of Labor and your employer if the plan is self-funded.
What your plan has to tell you
When a plan denies a claim, it generally must explain in writing:
Which claim was denied, including the date of service, provider, and amount billed
The specific reason. For a medical necessity denial, it must say why.
Any additional information that would let the claim be paid
Your appeal rights and where to find consumer help
You can also request the clinical guidelines the plan used to make its decision. Ask for them. They show you exactly what your appeal needs to address.
If ongoing care is being cut off
If the plan is reducing or ending treatment it previously approved, you typically have stronger protections. These include advance notice, an expedited appeal, and in many cases continued coverage while the appeal is decided. Say clearly that you are appealing a termination of ongoing care.
What to include in your appeal packet
A cover letter. Summarize what's been happening, why treatment is needed, why the plan denied it, and why it should be covered. If treatment has already happened, describe it. Include a short history of your contact with the plan, especially anything you believe went wrong. The Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project shares sample outlines for residential treatment and ABA appeal letters at mhautism.org.
The denial letter or EOB.
Clinical documentation. Evaluations, medical records, and letters from treating clinicians that describe the challenges, the recommended type and frequency of treatment, goals, and the treatment plan.
Supporting research, if the plan questions whether the treatment works.
A summary of any legal or procedural violations you believe occurred.
Know the deadlines
Under federal claims rules described by the U.S. Department of Labor, plans have short deadlines to decide. Urgent requests are decided within about 72 hours. Pre-service requests and appeals take weeks, and post-service appeals can take up to about 60 days. Many states and plans set shorter limits. Your plan documents should also say whether you need one or two levels of internal appeal before moving on.
After the internal appeal
If the plan upholds its denial, you can usually request an external review or contact your regulator. The Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project also suggests that families talk with an attorney at this stage about whether external review or other legal options make more sense.
Where to get more help
The Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project is a nonprofit that helps California families get mental health and autism care covered by insurance. Its Requesting Treatments & Managing Denials guide is the basis for this series, and the team there can help with complex cases. Visit mhautism.org for its full set of resources.
Refine Psychiatry clinicians can prepare documentation letters for patients in their care. Letters are a listed service in our fee schedule.
How Refine Psychiatry fits in
Refine Psychiatry is an out-of-network practice. We don't bill insurance directly, but we can give you a superbill to submit to your plan for possible reimbursement. When your plan asks for clinical documentation, we can also prepare letters as a listed service. You can see our current fees on our services page and our billing transparency page. Questions? Contact our team.
This article is general information for patients and families. It is not legal, insurance, or financial advice. Insurance rules vary by plan type and state and can change, so confirm the details with your plan, your plan documents, or a qualified advocate.


