Tips

When Your Insurance Has No Qualified Providers: Network Adequacy and Single Case Agreements

a woman sitting at a table talking on a cell phone

Sometimes your plan's directory has nobody nearby with the right experience, or everyone listed has a months-long waitlist. That's a network problem, and you have options. This guide is based on resources from the Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project.

Part of our insurance resource series: Requesting treatment & prior authorization · Out-of-network claims & reimbursement · When your plan has no qualified providers · Appealing a denial · External review & expedited appeals

Start with the plan's provider list

Get the current in-network list from your plan's website or member services. Then call the listed providers yourself and ask:

  • Are you accepting new patients, and how soon could we be seen?

  • Do you have experience treating this specific condition? For example, autism, a developmental disability, or an eating disorder.

  • Do you see patients in my child's age group?

Write down who you called, when, and what they said. If you are offered a waitlist spot, it's fine to accept it while you keep looking.

Know the distance and timeliness standards

States set network adequacy standards that limit how far plans can expect you to travel and how long you can be made to wait. In California, the Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project has described tighter distance limits for mental health care than for some medical services in state-regulated plans. For a child who can't tolerate long car rides, it may also be reasonable to argue that a far-away provider isn't truly available. Standards differ by plan type and county and can change, so check the current rules with your plan or state regulator. Self-funded employer plans follow their own plan documents.

Ask for a single case agreement

If no in-network provider has the right expertise or availability, tell your plan that its network is inadequate for your needs. Then ask for a single case agreement, or similar network exception, so you can see a qualified out-of-network provider.

According to the Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project, when a plan agrees to this, you generally pay in-network cost sharing, and this can apply in PPOs too. When you make the request:

  • List the in-network providers you contacted and why each one couldn't help

  • Name the out-of-network provider you'd like to see, if you have one

  • Ask for the plan's decision in writing, and get a reference number

If the plan doesn't respond adequately, you can file a complaint with your state regulator. In California, that is the Department of Managed Health Care or the Department of Insurance, depending on your plan.

Where to find qualified providers

Other parents, local support groups, and physicians who know your condition are often the best sources of names. NAMI affiliates and autism support organizations in your area may also help.

Where to get more help

The Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project is a nonprofit that helps California families get mental health and autism care covered by insurance. Its Requesting Treatments & Managing Denials guide is the basis for this series, and the team there can help with complex cases. Visit mhautism.org for its full set of resources.

How Refine Psychiatry fits in

Refine Psychiatry is an out-of-network practice. We don't bill insurance directly, but we can give you a superbill to submit to your plan for possible reimbursement. When your plan asks for clinical documentation, we can also prepare letters as a listed service. You can see our current fees on our services page and our billing transparency page. Questions? Contact our team.

This article is general information for patients and families. It is not legal, insurance, or financial advice. Insurance rules vary by plan type and state and can change, so confirm the details with your plan, your plan documents, or a qualified advocate.

Continue Reading