Tips
Independent Medical Review, Expedited Appeals, and California Insurance Regulators

If your plan upholds a denial after its internal appeal, an outside reviewer or a state regulator can often step in. Here's how that works for mental health and autism care, especially in California. This guide is based on resources from the Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project.
Part of our insurance resource series: Requesting treatment & prior authorization · Out-of-network claims & reimbursement · When your plan has no qualified providers · Appealing a denial · External review & expedited appeals
What is an independent (external) medical review?
In an independent medical review (IMR), an outside medical expert reviews your case. The reviewer works for an independent review organization, not your health plan. They look at your records and the medical literature and decide whether the denied treatment is needed for your situation.
It generally applies to medical necessity denials and to denials that call a treatment experimental or unproven.
Procedural problems in how your claim was handled may also qualify you for external review.
You don't pay for it. The plan or employer does.
Disputes about experimental treatment may be reviewed by a panel rather than a single expert.
Tip: when the review organization contacts you, confirm that it received your entire file, including the number of pages. The Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project has seen cases where the plan didn't send everything.
Reuse your appeal packet
You can usually send the same cover letter and documents from your internal appeal, with two updates:
Add any new reports or changes in health status.
Respond directly to the plan's appeal decision. Correct any wrong facts and explain where you disagree with its reasoning.
Who regulates your plan in California?
California has two health plan regulators, and which one you contact depends on your coverage:
Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC): generally regulates HMOs, most Covered California plans, many Blue Shield of California and Anthem Blue Cross plans, and many Medi-Cal managed care plans.
California Department of Insurance (CDI): generally regulates other PPO, indemnity, and some point-of-service policies.
If your plan was issued in another state, your plan documents should say which state's rules apply. Self-funded employer plans fall under federal rules. The U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration can help with those. Your denial letter should explain how to request external review.
When to ask for an expedited (urgent) review
You can usually ask for faster handling when waiting could seriously harm your health. In that situation you may be able to go to the regulator or external reviewer while the internal appeal is still underway. Ask for expedited review when:
Previously approved care is being ended, or reduced in amount or frequency
Delays in care could cause serious or lasting harm
Your plan documents define your situation as urgent
For autism services in California, the Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project points to state regulations that recognize how harmful delays in behavioral health treatment can be for children with autism. Families in state-regulated plans may be able to cite them when asking for expedited handling.
If you can't get coverage through work
If your employer's plan won't cover the care your family needs, you may be able to buy an individual, state-regulated plan through Covered California or a licensed broker. Plans can't charge more for pre-existing conditions. Enrollment usually opens in the fall, and a qualifying life event can let you enroll at other times.
Where to get more help
The Mental Health & Autism Insurance Project is a nonprofit that helps California families get mental health and autism care covered by insurance. Its Requesting Treatments & Managing Denials guide is the basis for this series, and the team there can help with complex cases. Visit mhautism.org for its full set of resources.
How Refine Psychiatry fits in
Refine Psychiatry is an out-of-network practice. We don't bill insurance directly, but we can give you a superbill to submit to your plan for possible reimbursement. When your plan asks for clinical documentation, we can also prepare letters as a listed service. You can see our current fees on our services page and our billing transparency page. Questions? Contact our team.
This article is general information for patients and families. It is not legal, insurance, or financial advice. Insurance rules vary by plan type and state and can change, so confirm the details with your plan, your plan documents, or a qualified advocate.


